Many of you know that I am a self-proclaimed Pinterest addict. Since I’m passionate about healthy recipes and healing nutrition, I follow many recipe and health boards and pinners. Not everyone I follow has the same nutrition philosophy as me, though. Bob Harper’s Skinny Rules list has appeared more than once in my Pinterest feed, and it never fails to thoroughly irk me. I can’t help but stage a mental debate over these rules every time I see that long yellow list.
These so-called skinny rules may lead to a temporary stress-hormone-fueled burst of weight loss, but it is not the key to real health and long-lasting weight management. Interestingly, some of these rules can actually backfire as weight gain.
1. Drink a large glass of water before every meal. No excuses.
Likely, the point here is to fill your stomach up with zero-calorie bulk, so you eat less. Bad idea.
While a small amount of water before meals can help prime the stomach for digestion, too much liquids with meals can water down the stomach acid and gastric juices. This lowers the pH of the stomach, which can lead to protein maldigestion (and that, in turn, leads to a leaky gut, food allergies, and insufficient neurotransmitter production). Read my post on how to heal stomach acid naturally for more info.
2. Don’t drink your calories.
We should absolutely avoid things like soda and pasteurized fruit juices (although freshly pressed fruit juices are full of vitamins and beneficial enzymes). Raw milk and homemade raw yogurt, however, are caloric beverages but are a fantastic source of nutrients and enzymes. So they absolutely have a place in the diet.
3. Slash your intake of refined flours and grains.
I do agree with this point, as my body has drastically healed while following a grain-free diet. Just remember: don’t fear carbs of natural sugars. And many people can tolerate properly prepared (soaked or fermented) grains. I will discuss this in Point 10.
4. Get 30 to 50 grams of fiber each day.
This absolutely boils my blood. DO NOT force yourself to consume copious amounts of fiber in the name of satiation of regularity. The body can thrive with very little fiber, and excessive fiber damages the digestive tract and actually harms metabolism. Read my post Is a High Fiber Diet a Health Hazard?
Further, eating a high fiber diet with the large amounts of water that Bob recommends can actually distend the stomach, so it requires gradually more and more food to feel full (Source).
Remember, constipation is a SYMPTOM of poor digestion and/or a stressful lifestyle. Address the root causes of constipation instead of using harmful amounts of dietary fiber to correct bowel movements. This may include reducing stress, removing processed foods, reducing and/or eliminating grains, increasing good dietary fat, correcting stomach acid levels and more. Here are natural steps to correct constipation that may be a helpful “band-aid.”
5. Eat apples and berries every day. Every. Single. Day.
There are so many things wrong with this seemingly innocent suggestion:
- Most berries are extremely high in oxalates, which can be a problem for those with leaky guts, autoimmune issues, arthritis, or inflammatory issues. Read my post Oxalates: The Grain Free Diet Trap for more details.
- Many berries are also goitrogens, meaning they suppress thyroid function and they should be eaten in moderation by those with hypothyroid issues.
- Raw apples are very high in pectin, which can be very hard to digest.
- Apples and many berries are high on the Dirty Dozen list for pesticides. Buy them organic or avoid them.
- Berries and apples are seasonal foods. I believe it is important to work towards a local, seasonal diet to support our environment and family farmers.
6. No carbs after lunch.
Protein should be consumed with a source of carbs for proper blood sugar regulation and digestion. Protein stimulates insulin, which stimulates for our muscle cells to assimilate amino acids. If sugar isn’t eaten to balance protein, insulin will pull sugar our of the blood, causing a sharp drop in blood sugar. A serving of starchy vegetables or a piece of fruit eaten with meals provides satiating carbs.
Finally, that just sounds miserable. Meals should be balanced and delicious, and it’s kind of impossible to have a really delicious meal without any carbs. Delicious meals are also more satiating than a bland protein and veggies combo.
8. Learn to read food labels so you know what you are eating.
Actually, there is LESS of a chance you will know what you are eating if you are eating something that has a food label. Shop for food that does not have a food label. Try searching your farmer’s market for local produce, pastured eggs, and grassfed meats. If you know the source, then you will know what you are eating.
9. Stop guessing about portion size and get it right.
I strongly advocate never eating anything “straight out of the package” to ensure you control the serving size. This means – for every meal and even snacks – to mindfully place your servings on to a plate. Don’t eat handfuls of nuts or pile chips on to a napkin and eat them in front of the TV. Often, when recovering from years of overeating, it is necessary to measure out the servings so you know that a proper serving size is. For example,
With that said, please do not obsess about calories. That leads to an emotionally-draining relationship with food. See my post, 5 Reasons Why Calories Don’t Count.
10. No more added sweeteners, including artificial ones.
Well, there is some truth in this. We should absolutely avoid artificial sweeteners. We should also avoid natural sugar-free sweeteners like stevia and xylitol when consumed without other carbohydrates, since these may trick the body into a state of hypoglycemia (read why I quit stevia).
When trying to lose weight, I recommend sourcing carbs from fruits and root vegetables and leaving out concentrated natural sweeteners. Once you have lost weight, I recommend using small amounts of whole, natural sweeteners (in moderation) like RAW honey, pure maple syrup, dried fruits, and dates. I discuss the importance of natural sugars in my post, Sugar: Your Body Needs It.
11. Get rid of those white potatoes.
Okay, this has some truth. Potatoes belong in the nightshade family of vegetables and are a reasonably inflammatory food. White potatoes are also high in starch, a polysaccharide which is hard for those with damaged digestive tracts to digest.
But for those with healthy digestive systems and low inflammation, white potatoes can be a great source of healthy carbohydrates. Just remember to eat it with at least a tablespoon of saturated fat (like butter or coconut oil) for balanced blood sugar!
12. Make one day a week meatless.
This is fine, and it is also a great way to stretch the grocery budget. Make sure to consume enough protein at meals without meat. Rely on nourishing meatless proteins (NO tofu!) like pastured eggs (I love eggs for dinner!). Properly soaked and cooked beans or legumes are tolerated by some, but can be hard on damaged digestive tracts.
13. Get rid of fast food and fried food.
Absolutely! Although homemade fries cooked in a healthy fat like beef tallow or coconut oil is a nourishing treat.
14. Eat a real breakfast.
TRUTH. Fuel your body with a balanced meal of carbs, protein and nourishing fats in the morning.
15. Make your own food and eat at least 10 meals a week at home.
This is not well stated–I don’t know if he means that you should prepare at least 10 meals a week or prepare all your meals but take them to work, etc.
There are 21 meals in a week and I think the vast majority of those meals should be prepared at home… not just 10. I think that it is best to make lunches at home or pack lunches to work or school.
16. Banish high-salt foods
Reducing high-salt foods usually entails reducing the processed foods in the diet. And while it is absolutely a vital step for health to reduce processed food consumption, it is NOT a healthy plan to restrict sodium.
A low sodium diet is dangerous. Studies show that a reduced-sodium diet leads to health issues like systemic insulin resistance and a shorter life span. (Here are 10 more reasons not to reduce the salt!) Further, adequate salt intake is necessary to hormone regulation, metabolism and hydration. Use unrefined sea salt, since it contains trace minerals, and salt your food to taste.
17. Eat your vegetables. Just do it.
I am going to blow some minds here: sometimes, vegetables are not ideal. Raw vegetables, in particular, can actually cause further damage in a weakened and inflamed digestive tract. In cases of hypothyroidism or a severely depressed metabolism, sometimes it is preferable temporarily favor easy-to-digest, “warming” foods like raw milk and fruit. I recommend the book Eat for Heat for more info.
Cooked vegetables – cooked from scratch yourself – are a better option because they provide bulk and nutrients without excessive calories.
18. Go to bed hungry.
You know what happens when I go to bed hungry? I’m crabby and I can’t sleep well. And I would bet this happens to most people. This is another one of Bob’s rules that actually undermines weight loss: it is difficult to go to sleep while hungry, and sleep is SO essential to healthy metabolism.
Eat a small but balanced snack before bed to help maintain stable blood sugar through the night. If you frequently wake up between 2 and 4 am, it means that you are having blood sugar drops. A spoonful of coconut oil before bed along with a piece of fruit makes an ideal bedtime snack.
19. Sleep right.
Well, that’s ironic. Bob is telling us to sleep immediately after he tells us to go to bed hungry.
But he is correct about this point. Sleep is a key part in healthy metabolism. One real nonnegotiable for effective weight loss is a 10 PM bedtime. Turn off the media one hour before bed and all women should practice the Lunaception night-lighting technique.
20. Plan on one splurge meal a week.
This is another rule that I think can backfire as weight gain. I think it creates the mentality of depriving yourself for the majority of your meals… which is an unhealthy relationship with food! It may lead to the toxic Restrict and Repent cycle discussed in the fantastic book The Nourished Metabolism. Every single meal–not just a once-a-week-splurge– should leave you satiated and happy.
When it comes to supporting a healthy metabolism and maintaining your ideal weight, The Skinny Rules are not an effective solution.
Are you familiar with The Skinny Rules? What are your thoughts about them?






Love love love this post!!
What kind of carb do you eat with your proteins?? Not fruit, right??
I also love this post! Great information backed up with supporting evidence.
Thank you, Lauren! This is exactly why I follow your blog!
I have the same question as above — What kind of carb do you eat with your proteins?
I did not know either that sugar should be consumed with protein.
Can you respond to my email with the answer?
Keep up the great work!!!!
Just a quick question: the list shows twenty points and you get back on track with number ten, but you missed point three (Eat protein at every meal – or stay hungry and grouchy) and threw the numbering off. What is your opinion on protein?
I was going to ask the same question.
She may not disagree with it.
I love the way you address each point thoughtfully and back up your reasoning. Living a healthy lifestyle is so much more than following someone’s arbitrary set of rules! Your blog is a tremendous resource and I appreciate all the work you put into it!
This is a great article on health but is totally irrelevant to the book. The book is about his rules to getting you thin! Not getting you healthy and how to live your life.
Being thin and being healthy are two things that are so often confused.
I’m sure his rules would make people thin but would do nothing for their overall health.
Your points are about allergies, sleep issues, inflammation, leaky gut etc. The book is about how to get you thin full stop.
I totally agree with your views but you didn’t bust his points or prove his SKINNY rules wrong, you provided information on why it’s not healthy to follow his rules.
nothing wrong with that
I agree with much of what you have to say. But I completely disagree with your thoughts on portion sizes.
About 2 years ago my husband and I transitioned to a real, whole foods diet, emphasizing raw milk, real fats, soaked grains, plenty of meat and some vegetables. My already overweight husband gained serious pounds, and my easily-gains-weight body gained a lot. Try 40 pounds a lot (plus an additional 20 in pregnancy). Turns out that 4 tablespoons of coconut oil, everything slathered in butter and two cups of raw whole milk a day will cause you to gain weight.
I’d finally switched to a low-fat, grain-free diet to try to loose something and managed to lose 30 pounds (which i’ve kept off for months). We’re now back to health fats and soaked grains, but working for SERIOUS moderation. We NEED sensible portion sizes (eating a pound of ground beef at a meal is not healthy, even if it does come from grass-fed cows), and many people at unhealthy weights need to be encouraged to eat moderate portions.
Many people like my husband and I do not receive correct signals from their bodies about satiation, so learning to eat off smaller plates, measure out our servings, and eating slowly are all important skills to master in order for us to loose weight and feel better.
No, I completely agree with you. The energy, in the for of calories, we take in does matter. We can’t take in more energy than we expend and expect to loose weight. They key is eating the foods in a way that boosts our metabolic function and helps us use energy more efficiently. I didn’t say in the post that you can eat all the real food you want and not expect to gain weight. As you have found out, it doesn’t work that way.
You raise some very good points and got me thinking, and I believe that was the whole point. I have changed my thoughts on eating over the years because I’ve seen how food affects me in different ways, and I am inclined to agree with a lot of what you say. I am not to the point you are, but I may get there…or I may not, and that’s ok. I do, however, think you make a lot of sense and have seen personally that a lot of what you say is indeed true (the rest I don’t know because I have not experienced personally). All in all, I do believe that our food is key to our health, and we need to pay a whole lot more attention to how we fuel it than we do! Great article, and I’m glad I took the time to read and share it (found you via Weed ‘Em and Reap)!
WOW. Fantastic article.
To those who think that Harpers book speaks to the obese and therefor his advice is sound, they are MISSING it. Weight loss should ALWAYS be a side effect of being healthy. Everything about Lauren’s comments support health in the body. When one focuses on simple weight loss/calories in to calories out mentality, they are most always nutrient depleted, damaging their thyroid, wreaking havoc on their pancreas with poor blood sugar management and MISERABLE!!! Any weight loss in this stressful environment is bound to come back! And the statics show that it does! Go Lauren, keep up the AWESOME work spreading the gospel of REAL food and vibrant health!
You mention a couple of times that you are not sure what Bob Harper means. Did you read the book or just the summary of the rules?
For me it sounds like, while Lauren has some good points, she hasn’t read the book.
Case in point drinking water before meals. Bob backs this up in his book with reference to clear studies showing the benefits, and it’s clear his intention is to not just fill you up. but as part of the making sure you get enough water in your diet
You’re right, I haven’t read the book. My purpose here was just to address the many fallacies in the Skinny Rules image/list that I see popping up everywhere. I want people to understand the serious problems with these rules before they start following the diet 🙂
I have a question about your opinion about drinking water before meals. You wrote that water dilutes gastric juices. Water has a pH of approx. 7 and stomach acid is roughly a pH of 2 so my understanding when conclude that that would increase the pH not lower it. Will you please explain this? Or did you mean lower the acidity?