Skip links

four

Vibrant health means you can live life to the fullest. Empower yourself with the steps I used to free my life of chronic disease and medications.

Reader Interactions

161 Comments

  1. I can buy RealSalt in bulk at my local natural grocery store for $1.99/lb.
    Could you clarify….RealSalt is not the same as himalayan salt? Is it not as good??
    I was buying it as an alternative to the Celtic Sea Salt b/c it was so much less expensive.
    What do you think of the Celtic SS?
    Thanks for your help.

    • I think Real Salt is a wonderful option, particularly because it is so affordable. I’ve worked with Real Salt before and it is a wonderful family-run company with awesome people. Comparing the two salts, Real Salt contains 60 trace minerals and Himalayan salt contains 84. These extra 24 trace minerals are important. Himalayan salt also makes superior sole because of the ionic and crystalline energetic properties of the salt. In my kitchen, I use both Real Salt and Himalayan Salt to get the mineral profiles from both salts!

      I no longer use any type of sea salt, the oceans are just becoming so polluted. Himalayan Salt and Real Salt are from ancient (250,000+ years ago) sea beds and so are free of modern ocean contaminants.

      • I’ve been in the market for, if nothing else, a SAFE table salt for my family. After doing allot of research, I came up with the SAME 3 brands that you listed! They are all great!

        Real Salt here in the USA, you can’t go wrong! However, I heard that their product is “gritty”. I called them and they sent me a sample! Their product is fantastic! (and not “gritty”)

        I contacted Himalasalt and was receiving emails directly from Melissa giving me every detail of where their salt is mined and how meticulously it is processed! They have nothing to hide!

        HOWEVER, I was concerned about one detail!!!!

        All of their products are packaged in Plastic!!! Real Salt in polyethylene (#1 PET). and Himalasalt in polypropylene (#5 PP).

        Will the plastics leach into the salt?

        I would pay extra if they were packaged in glass containers!

      • Y’all are ridiculously uneducated. AMONG THOSE 86 trace minerals in Himalayan pink salt are: radium, thallium, uranium and plutonium. I would prefer NOT to have radioactive substances in my salt.

      • Dear All,
        This is good discussion about Sodium Chloride (Salt). Pakistan is the largest source of natural Rock Salt pink and read which has got more minerals source. There is belt of mines in Pakistan controlled by the government of Pakistan. We are exporting throughout the world.
        Shabbir H. Bokhari
        shabbir.h.bokhari

  2. I used himalayan salt for years until recently I read several articles about the pink colour comes from inorganic iron (iron oxide) with is toxic to the body (ray peat). what do you say about that?

    • Hmmm, that is new to me. I think Ray Peat has wonderful points, but I take some of his dietary recommendations with a grain of salt (pun intended!) 🙂 I’ll certainly read what he has to say, though. Dr. Mercola, whom I trust in regards to many aspects of health, highly recommends the consumption of himalayan salt.

  3. Hi there,
    I enjoy reading all of your posts. I had a question about the sole. Why can’t you use metal? I unknowingly used a metal spoon to scoop it out a few days. Did I harm myself? Did I ruin this batch?
    thanks for all your wisdom!
    Denise

  4. Hi Lauren! Thanks for the informative post!! You work so hard to bring us good info!

    I had a question about Himalayan salt – I had read on a Facebook GAPS group that Himalayan salt might have contaminants in it . . . we use Redmond’s but I’ve read about the benefits of sole with Himalayan salt. Have you read anything about contamination (arsenic, etc.?).

    Thanks and blessings!

  5. Hi Lauren, Thank you so much for your very informative information. I want to try Sole for a condition i have called Meibomian Gland Disorder (MGD). It is where your eyelids are clogged and don’t allow the natural oil out that lubricates your eye balls. It results in major dry eyes, blepharitis and it’s very uncomfortable. Basically, you have a bacteria similar to acne and one of the treatments is to take tetracyline for 3 months! Which i won’t do…. I know you cannot give medical advice, but I was wondering in your research if you’ve come across this disorder and have a suggestion. I have tried numerous things with no relief. I’ve upped my EFA’s, tried coconut oil, castor oil in my eyes, drops of all sorts. Also thought I might have allergies, but tested negative on al the tests. Thanks again. I love your blog!

    • Hi Maura Mark,

      I accidentally stumbled across your comment. I just wanted to let you know that there’s a young lady with a chronic case of blepharitis, and she simply made her own “probiotic” eye drops which has improved her condition! I don’t think they sell this anywhere, so you will have to make your own. And there were studies done on probiotics in the eyes with great results! Here is the link to the forum where the young lady left her comment & instructions on how she made her own probiotic eye drops. I wish you all the best with your eyes!
      Here is link (copy & paste to browser)
      http://treato.com/Eye+Drops,Probiotic/?pix=0

    • My commended that I take 3000grams of omega 3 fish oil from PRN for my dry eyes and tow low down macular degeneration along with Preservision AREDS 2. After a month, I not only experienced relief forum dry eyes, but also saw a dramatic improvement in my chronic dry skin and extemporaneous. PRN is formulated to be odorless and highly absorbable by the body. We are using our first Himalayan salt lamp we found on sale at Tuesday Morning.

  6. Hi Lauren,
    I was using Himalayan salt but my naturopath has me switch to Celtic SS saying that for my colitis it had better health benefits. What is your thought on the two salts and would a Celtic salt sole be beneficial? I’m new to all this!

      • i would be cautious with the use of any open flame:
        1. it requires oxygen and expels carbon dioxide;
        2. it generates carbon which we are trying to eliminate from our atmosphere,
        you will recognize as black streaks and blotches in the area of the flame;
        3. if any combustible item should get too close, a fire could result;
        4. would the deposits on the salt affect its efficacy, artificially reduce its effectiveness?
        5. the wax properties may vary between candles, but would no doubt contribute other
        chemicals to the surrounding air, over and above the carbon issue identified in 2.

        I think someone who is qualified might want to discuss this and confirm or refute these and any other questions that might arise concerning the use of open flame in salt lamps.

      • My first attempt was rejected on the basis that I had submitted the same material before, is it totally lost? Unless I accidentally tried to submit before I was finished, but doubt this and in any event it would have been incomplete and without any ID? Very strange…

        I was concerned about the use of an open flame near anything combustible;
        the introduction of carbon into the air and onto the salt;
        wax properties and impurities introduced into the air, and onto the salt;
        reduction of oxygen and increase of carbon dioxide.

  7. I am anemic right now and trying everything to get my health back on track the “clean and natural” way. Hope this helps – makes sense to do even if it doesn’t help anemia. Looking forward to helping with balancing hormones too.
    Thanks for all your interesting posts. I love them all!!

    • For anemia the best thing i have found is Laktoferrin / Lactoferrin. It will take the iron from where ever it is being stored and not used and put it to where it should be. I have parasites and they use the iron to build their biofilms. The lactoferrin works everytime i become anemic. You can also take seasame seed oil or seeds and anything that you eat with iron in it take with Vit C to drive the iron into blood cells. Taking iron supplements usually doesnt work. Spirulina with Vit C is also great.

  8. I wonder if you drink RO water could you put a teaspoon or tablespoon of this into it to remineralise – I usually put a pinch of Himalayan salt into it – would it be the same thing or better?

  9. I have 2 questions about using the salt in baths:
    1: Won’t the salt dry out the skin?
    and 2: Can I still add essential oils to the bath water? Or whatever else goes in baths?

  10. Hi Lauren,

    thank you for the detailed post on himalayan salt.
    I’ll be making the sole and here is my question – since I’m oilpulling first thing in the morning, followed by drinking two cups of warm water + the juice of one lemon, where does the salt sole fit?
    What should be the sequence?

    • ha, ha, I was typing out the exact same question when I looked up and saw your post! I will be waiting to see what she says. I wonder if the sole would ruin the taste of my lemon water? Or if there is some weird reason you cannot mix the sole and lemon water.

    • Despite conventional wisdom, salt doesnt raise blood pressure, and removing significant amounts of sodium from the diet barely knocks 1 point off your bp for hypertensive individuals. However, sodium is very important for electrolyte balance, if you eat a whole food diet with no grains your not getting much in your food. The average person can tolerate and is beneficial to consume much more than current recommended limits.

  11. Hi Lauren –
    Thanks for sharing your wealth of knowledge!
    I am a daily visitor to your site and have learned a lot.
    Yesterday I used your recipe to make sole. I currently drink a glass of water with lemon & raw ACV in the mornings – what is your opinion on adding a tsp of sole to the lemon/acv water? Am I better off replacing the lemon/acv water with just the sole in the morning?
    Thank you!!

  12. Hi Lauren – I am fairly new to your site but have really enjoyed it so far and I’ve signed up for email updates. I have just read all of your salt articles back to back and think they’re great – I have always been a huge fan of salt and am forever telling people not to cut down, the opposite in fact but just to choose better! At first I didn’t know how I knew that it’s vitally important and beneficial for us, it was just like knowing to breathe but since then I have attended salt workshops and researched more – although I think I still know less than you. It’s fantastic to encounter a fellow salt enthusiast!

    Best wishes from London, Francesca

  13. I would think that with each element having differing atomic weights the only minerals you would be spooning out would be the ones that are the least dense by weight. The rest simply will simply settle downward.

  14. Can you please tell me the source of information for the “84 trace minerals vital for wellbeing”? I cannot find a lab study anywhere. Surely this must have been tested in a lab at some point for this information to be accurate, right? Can you please share where you got this information? Thank you very much!

  15. Makes me wonder if these people even go out in public, I mean its like – oh my god I might catch something and die! Really? You people just believe what the hell you want and that’s it. You said one thing and Darryl said another. “Why is it important to avoid using metal utensils or a metal lid? According to my friend Darryl, who works at Real Salt:” Hell, if ya read the comment good old Darryl said in his owne damn words that it’s OK to use metal utensils.

  16. Hello,

    We are basically Manufacturers and Exporters of Himalayan Edible Salts, Bath Salts, Salt Inhalers and Salt products such as lamps, tiles, block, bricks and many more.

    We also have Lapis Lazuli, Tawas Crystal ALUM and Dried Rose Petals products availabe,

    We also make Himalayan Salt Caves, Salt rooms, Salt Walls and much more. For more info and designs, please see our new website caves.multirocksalt.com

    We are also ISO 9001:2000, HACCP AND FDA approved Company,

    We are Proud to announce that we have made the world’s tallest salt crystal lamp,

    Height 8 feet and 4 inches and weight approx 3500 KG,

    Also visit our website to see the world’s biggest salt crystal Lamp,

    We gained trust and good reputation in international market as most popular brands in Europe, USA and Far East countries are using our products regularly.

    Thanks,

    Questions?

    Roshaan Hussain | Marketing Director | Multi Rock Salt Company
    U.S Office: +1 (415) 513 0044 | Pakistan Office: +92 300 490 5739 | Skype : multi.rocksalt
    http://www.multirocksalt.com | info@multirocksalt.com / multi.rocksalt@gmail.com

  17. I don’t understand what you are taking in when you are ingesting the sole. so you mix salt and water and let it sit and then use a teaspoon for what? mix the salt up and scoop from the bottom or top? you are ingesting salt and water or basically just very salty water (so no actual salt grains on it?)

    and when you say “use a glass jar” how big?

  18. sorry I see that you say mix the teaspoon full into one glass of water but I still need clarification on what is in that teaspoon. thanks so much! (I use real salt for everything, love living in utah!)

  19. hi…

    i like himalayan sole and drink it first thing in the morning…but 2 weeks ago i got diagnosed with hashimoto’s disesase…i was wondering if you have any info about usage of himalayan sole in hashimoto’s disease
    thanks

  20. well now I’m more confused than ever! At the top of the page you said:
    UPDATE: As it turns out, Real Salt, Celtic Salt, and Himalayan Salt share the same number and type of minerals. The “84 minerals” in himalayan salt is an unsupported claim. I had the opportunity to speak with a salt expert and I shared how unrefined salts compare, as well as concerns about contaminants in the salt.
    Now in the comments you are saying REAL salt has 60 trace minerals, and Himalayan salt has 84 which seems extremely contradictory to me

  21. I’m very interested in trying Sole. But I have to warn against the salt baths. I added 1 cup of deep sea salt to my bath one time and ended up giving myself horrible burns – it was worse than the worst sunburn I’d ever have. My skin literally came off in shreds. Disgusting and pretty dangerous. I was in pain for over a week.

  22. My husband has been using the Sole for about 2 1/2 weeks and has had continual severe headaches and his food tastes terrible now, really anything he eats tastes bad. He’s noticed that his arthritis is a bit better but is wondering what’s worse; the hit and miss stiffness of the joints or headaches and unenjoyable meals. Have you had anyone else say they’ve had such negative side affects?

  23. Hey, thanks for this interesting article on Himalayan salt, especially on the salt sole creation. I always thought that dissolving 1 tsp of hima salt in a cup and drinking it will suffice. Looks like creating salt sole will “drain” out the mineral ions from the hima salt, which is a really good technique!

    I just curious why Himalayan salt is pink in colour though…there’s an article which states that Himalayan salt is actually pink due to high iron (Fe 3+ ions) concentration. If that’s the case, wouldn’t it be bad to drink too much concentrated salt solution? I’m not sure what these iron ions can do to the body. You can find the article here: http://himalayansaltlamp.org/himalayan-pink-salt-benefits/

    Apart from that, I really like the Himalayan salt lamps in your post. They look really appealing and I’ll probably consider getting them for my home.

  24. I would like to know how to use Himalayan pink salt and Mediterranean sea salt as a replacement for regular salt. If used in a recipe for hamburgers, will it melt into the meat or stay whole? Does it have to be ground?

  25. Hi Lauren,

    I just wanted to sincerely thank you for this Excellent article. It was clear, easy to understand and informative and an interesting read for me on this subject. I am one of those who was under the impression that all salts are an absolute no because my body tends to retain water and fluctuate my weight often.

    I was promoted to read your article as I started researching this salt solely because I found Kale chips at our local Whole Foods and have been terrified as to how it would after my weight since the majority of them are made well but with Pink Himalayan Salt added.

    Thank you so much for this helpful info on Pink Himalayan and Real salts. I will use this information to help my family too.

    Sincerely,
    YS
    NJ, USA

  26. I put Himalayan salt in water throughout the day, in addition to the morning sole, to help hydration. I’ve heard that salt water/ sole can erode tooth enamel, but some say it strengthens it.

    Any ideas or resources? Thank you!

  27. Your article was wonderful and very informative! Thank you! My next step is to buy some Himalayan sea salt to replace my table salt. I do have a question. I recently purchased the pink sea salt blocks for foot detox and wondered how often and for how long they should be used. I’ve only just gotten them and used them a couple times …. I love them! I also bought the large pink sea salt slab for cooking … haven’t tried that yet though! Thank you so much for your time!

  28. Hey…

    i can use Milled Himalayan Salt for the sole? ive just ordered 1kg of Ground Himalayan Salt and they sent me 15 days after milled himalayan salt…it dosent work for the sole?

  29. I suffer from migraine headaches. I do take medication that helps a lot. But if/when I feel the beginning of a migraine I mix 1/2 tsp. Himalayan sea salt with the juice of 1/2 of lemon. I drink it right down (in a shot glass!) and the feeling of a migraine goes away.

  30. hello, i just had the opportunity of hearing about himalayan crystal salt and have bought some. i have high blood pressure and was a bit skeptical, but after reading the benefits i’ll try it in my foods.

  31. If you live in the Kissemee area there is a very large awesome store in OLD TOWN that sells rocks and shells, They have many varietes and sizes of SALT Rock lights. I have two in my home and leave them on all day llong- The air in my townhouse just smells cleaner and I feel better when they are on. Plus they are very pretty as well. I have one in my fireplace – (I never use the fireplace).. looks awesome.

  32. I am new to your site. I tried reading all of the comments on this post, but I ran out of time:). My questions are these – 1) Do you have a preferred place to purchase the salt lamp. I would hate to buy a “fake” one. 2) I am on Synthroid and Armour thyroid meds and am also anemic. The thyroid meds and iron (Florvital) cannot be taken together and also have to be separated from my coffee. When would be the best time to drink the sole and how many times a day can/should it be taken? Thank you very much.

  33. Hello,

    I would like to inform about my supply of Natural Salt lamps and I have read comments about people asking where to buy original salt lamps from… then i would like to tell you that I am based in Pakistan and salt is a natural resource here so please be kind to visit my website and if you think you can refer someone to me please be kind to do so.

    Thanks.

  34. I just started this, I’ve noticed a slight metallic taste in my mouth. i was wondering if you experienced something similar or if it’s just my body adjusting to more minerals.

    Thanks!

  35. I am trying to decide where to purchase Himalayan Salt factoring in quality and price (I am on a very tight budget). I know there is Salt Works, the most affordable of the three you mentioned, but there is also Himalayan Treasures at http://selectorganix.com/salt/himalayan-salt and San Francisco Salt at http://www.sfsalt.com/home. Do you know anything about either of those two.? I would be so disappointed if I made the wrong decision because I am trying so hard to get my “older” family on the right track.
    Thank you.

  36. Hi, Lauren!
    I bought in Ireland Hymalayan salt and used it in food. On the pakage it says “just for external use. Make sure you have no cuts as it is for detox.”
    Are there different types of hymalayan salt?
    My thyroid has swollen over night and I’m checking if the salt has anything to do with it.
    Thank you so much.
    Alina

  37. The absolutely only thing wrong with this article is that she mentioned that you should get a little “salt” with the SOLE… this is not a good idea if your diet is already high in sodium you should avoid doing this…

    (Regardless if its table salt, or Pink Himalayan salt, they can both increase BP, and HR., the minerals don’t somehow make it less bad for you, this is not magic, too much of anything can poison you.)

    The correct way of using SOLE is to fill the jar approx 1/2 to 3/4ths with coarse unrefined Himalayan pink salt then fill with water and shake the hell out of it until the water becomes supersaturated with salt to the point that the rock salt starts precipitating out of the mixture The pink cloud at the top IS the minerals. When you take your teaspoon in the morning swirl the jar until the water becomes cloudy pink… then scoop from the top where all the minerals are, this helps minimize the sodium intake while maximize the minerals consumed. Refill and re saturate the water each time you add more water… the point to SOLE is that its supersaturated to the point that the minerals fall out of solution.,

    I guess the metal lid thing is true, I mean it happens to cars near the ocean, but it takes years to cause any decay in metals from seawater.. and generally they are cars that are parked near the ocean for 5-10 years… So maybe if your metal lid is constantly touched by the Pink salt sole it may cause decay… in a few months of exposure. Just check the lid for corrosion and replace if necessary, upgrade to a glass jar with a glass lid and a rubber seal.

    • Yes its fine to shake it after you add more water, but always wait for it to settle before you scoop your Teaspoon of Sole.

      Also make sure you use a plastic or glass lid on your glass jar… the sole starts corroding the metal lids within a month, its crazy how fast they start rusting… Rust is bad because it has rust bacteria in it..

  38. HI!! I use lemon essential oil in my water upon waking every morning. I have drank sole water before. I was wondering if I can incorporate the 2 in the same glass or do the salt first or lemon oil first. Thanks!

  39. My question is this. Is the grit I’m chewing at the bottom of a bowl of chicken broth or in my scrambled eggs the salt? I know it’s not bones or shells. Its very rock-y. It doesn’t bother me other than make me think I’m etching the enamel of my teeth. I don’t want to damage my teeth or anyone else who happens to eat my food!

  40. Are you really getting a significant dose of these minerals in the 1 tsp of himalayan salt?? I doubt it- they are likely available in trace amounts and unfortunately will not truly serve as a multimineral supplement. It is dangerous to be recommending high salt intake for the general public because this includes african americans with hypertension who are generally salt-sensitive, people with kidney disease who cannot regular salt properly due to reduced glomerular filtration capacity, and those with congestive heart failure as salt intake has osmotic effects while lead to excessive fluid gains which suppress the heart and lungs. Please, look over the research before you provide uneducated, one-sided nutrition recommendations to the unsuspecting public.

  41. I bought some Himalayan rock salt that comes in rocks in a glass jar with a metal lid and metal grater. All of a sudden I see black stuff growing on some of the rocks. Can it be mold? What can I do? Some of the rocks look normal. Please help! I do live in a humid area.

  42. Hi Lauren, your page hgas been very informative to my wife Hazel and I. Hazel, during her life of past 80 years, not only has been an active one, but medically challenging with breast Cancer, a Meningioma ( now cleared) now suffering Atrial Fibrillation and COPD. Both of us have never smoked but come from families that did.
    We were surprised to find the medical fraternity has now valued knowledge of Himalayan Salt value; at least, our Gp says he has knowledge of its use! . . and we have known him since 1985.
    We are about to embarque on this path to try to give Hazel some relief of her breathing and COPD.. Already researching the ebays and Amazons etc, whom we have used for good products in the past. We look forward to reading your newsletters.
    regards Geoff&Hazel Isaac

  43. Hi there. I have problems with fluid retention. I loved hearing about the benefits of Himalayan salt, but would like to know if it would contribute to fluid retention. Does anyone know? Thanks.

  44. I sell Himalayan salt for a living…. If you use ground salt for your sole, it will change the frequency of the water, just as using a metal spoon or lid, since it has been ground with metal grinders. Use chunks specifically for sole, that has not touched metal!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Lauren Geertsen, NTP

I’m an author, entrepreneur, and nutritional therapy practitioner (NTP). I began this website at 19, to share the steps that freed my life of chronic disease and medication. Now, Empowered Sustenance has reached 30 million readers with healthy recipes and holistic resources.

Lauren’s Books

Get simple steps fordelivered weekly

(plus exclusive coupons and other subscriber-only resources!)

No thanks, I don’t want to sign up.